ByLawyers News and Updates

Testamentary capacity checklist

by

A testamentary capacity checklist has been added to the matter plans in all By Lawyers will guides. This helpful precedent distills the critical information that practitioners must elicit to properly assess capacity. It is designed to assist lawyers both when taking instructions and when the will is being executed, whether in the office or at the client’s bedside.

Whether or not a client has testamentary capacity is not calculated via a legislated formula but derived from case law. It has been described as requiring time, situation, person, and task specific focus on a testator’s ability to remember, reflect, and reason.

The cases, starting from Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549 require a testator to understand:

  • what it means to be making a will;
  • the assets they have and are leaving to others;
  • the obligation owed to those who could make a claim on the estate; and
  • whether or not they are affected by a delusion that influences the disposal of their assets.

The Court determines testamentary capacity on the facts and circumstances of each case.

In Star v Miller [2021] NSWSC 426, the court said that, when taking instructions, it is prudent for lawyers to ascertain the client’s capacity and the possibility of undue influence by asking non-leading questions to determine the facts and circumstances of each case. The By Lawyers testamentary capacity checklist includes such questions.

In Ryan v Dalton; Estate of Ryan [2017] NSWSC 1007 at 107, the court suggests that where an elderly client is being cared for by someone or is residing in an aged care facility, it is prudent to ask both clients and their carers whether there is any reason to be concerned about capacity. The By Lawyers testamentary capacity checklist prompts for these inquiries to be made.

The checklist was suggested by one of our subscribers. We worked with our authors to draft a document that is as short and simple as possible but protects practitioners by covering all necessary considerations. The checklist should be used in conjunction with the By Lawyers Wills retainer instructions.

Wills guide reviewed – WA

by

The continuing commitment of By Lawyers to updating and enhancing our publications has seen the Western Australian Wills guide reviewed.

Subscribers using this popular publication will benefit from a re-ordered and extended matter plan, revised and updated commentary and a number of new precedents.

Execution is now a top-level heading on the matter plan, with dedicated commentary on issues such as blind witnesses, gifts to witnesses and solicitors as witnesses. The revisions and enhancements to commentary also include:

  • First steps and taking instructions for wills
  • Testamentary capacity and the test in Banks v Goodfellow
  • The formal requirements for a valid will
  • Informal wills
  • Intestacy
  • Executors
  • Execution
  • Challenges to the validity of a will

New and amended precedents

  • Letter to client to confirming instructions
  • Instructions for signing
  • Letter reminding client that will is ready for signing

Other resources in the Wills guide reviewed

Links have been added to the By Lawyers reference materials Other trusted and useful resources, which can be found in the Reference materials folder on the matter plan and at the end of the full commentary.

COVID measures are here to stay – All states

by

Many temporary COVID measures introduced across Australia during the pandemic are here to stay.

New South Wales and Queensland have now proposed legislation permanently retaining some COVID measures, such as remote witnessing. Victoria have already legislated to retain some COVID measures. The Commonwealth has extended temporary measures for companies.

With other states and territories expected to follow suit, the long-term legal legacy of COVID-19 looks like being significant.

New South Wales

The Electronic Transactions Amendment (Remote Witnessing) Bill 2021 will permanently allow certain documents to be witnessed in real time over an audio-visual link.

Further, for an additional 12 months from the date of assent, the list of people who can witness NSW statutory declarations will be extended to the expanded list of witnesses set out in Schedule 2 of the Statutory Declarations Regulations 2018.

Queensland

The Justice and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2021 will make permanent some of Queensland’s  temporary COVID measures including:

  • Remote witnessing and electronic signing of affidavits, statutory declarations and some oaths; however electronic signatures on statutory declarations can only be used for a land or water dealing where electronic conveyancing is used.
  • Powers of attorney for corporations, partnerships and unincorporated associations, but not sole traders, can be signed electronically, in counterpart, by split execution and without a witness; however, if a general power of attorney is used for a land or water dealing it must continue to be executed in accordance with the Land Title Act 1994 and Land Act 1994.
  • Advance health directives can be certified as to capacity by nurses, in addition to doctors.
  • Deeds can be made in the form of an electronic document, electronically signed, made in counterpart and by split execution, generally without a witness. The Bill also removes the requirement for deeds to be sealed, requiring the deed to contain a clear statement that it is executed as a deed. However, deeds lodged or deposited in relation to land and water dealings must continue to be executed in accordance with the Land Title Act 1994 and Land Act 1994.
  • Private applications for temporary protection orders in domestic and family violence matters may be filed electronically, with a hearing date allocated and the application served before the application is verified. Verification can occur later, when the magistrate hears the application. The Magistrates Court may hear any part of family and domestic violence proceedings by audio visual link.

South Australia

The Oaths (Miscellaneous) Amendment Act 2021 commencing on 1 December 2021 amends the Oaths Act 1936 (SA) to:

  • Provide continuity following the expiration of the COVID-19 Emergency Response Act 2020 and its associated regulations through the Oaths Regulations 2021.
  • Introduce a Code of Practice – Affidavits to be followed by deponents and witnesses in the making of affidavits.
  • Introduce a Code of Practice – Statutory Declarations to be followed by declarants, and witnesses to ensure statutory declarations are taken in accordance with the Oaths Act 1936.
  • Expand the persons before whom a statutory declaration may be made as stated in the new Schedule 1 to the Oaths Act 1936.
  • Include additional offences for those falsely representing themselves as authorised witnesses to a statutory declaration or affidavit.

By Lawyers keeps you up to date

All relevant By Lawyers guides, including the dedicated guide Dealing with COVID-19 legal issues – Some practical information which appears at the top of all By Lawyers matter plans, have been or will be updated to reflect these changes as and when they take effect.

Automated wills – All states

by

As part of By Lawyers continual commitment to enhancement, the By Lawyers Wills publications in each state now feature more automated wills, particularly for LEAP users. There is improved automation in all wills precedents – Individual wills, Wills for couples and Wills creating testamentary discretionary trusts.

The wills precedents are available in folder ‘C. The Will’ on the matter plans in By Lawyers Wills publications in each state.

Fields have been added to the bequest clauses in all wills. This allows users to populate the precedents with any information they have  completed in the ‘Bequest’ table type in a LEAP wills matter. This applies for each beneficiary added to a LEAP matter:

The bequest clause in all automated wills now provides for up to four beneficiaries. The clauses will now automatically include information based on whether a sum, a gift, or a sum AND a gift, have been completed in the table type for the LEAP matter:

LEAP users can select ‘Is primary beneficiary’, which will add the beneficiary to the residue clause:

Introduction of the LEAP for Word add-in allows LEAP users to also complete additional information in a will. This functionality prompts the will-drafter for such input as the person to whom the testator wishes to bequeath their residuary estate:

For further information on using the LEAP for Word add-in, see the helpful article ‘Working with By Lawyers precedents’ available in Folder A. Getting the matter underway, on the matter plans in all By Lawyers publications.

Please do not hesitate to contact By Lawyers with any questions of feedback on these enhancements: askus@bylawyers.com.au

Family Property List – VIC

by

New commentary and a link to the VIC County Court Family Property List practice note has been added to the By Lawyers Family Provision Claims guides for Victoria. This applies to both Acting for the plaintiff and Acting for the estate.

The commentary focuses mainly on the Supreme Court where most applications are filed, but the new section suggests that consideration should always be given to whether the plaintiff’s claim is more appropriately filed in the County Court. There is no monetary limit on the County Court’s jurisdiction.

Paragraph 1.3 of the County Court’s Family Property List practice note sets out the factors which make a case suitable for the County Court.

The decision as to which court any proceedings should be commenced in may involve consideration of the obligations upon parties and their legal representatives under Chapter 2 of the Civil Procedure Act 2010 – the ‘overarching obligations’.

If the plaintiff’s decision to file in the Supreme Court is based on a reasonable assessment that the factors in paragraph 1.3 of the Family Property List practice note do not apply it would be very hard to argue that a party, or their lawyer, was in breach of their obligations under Chapter 2 of the Civil Procedure Act 2010 by filing there. However, conversely, a decision by the plaintiff to file in the Supreme Court where those factors do apply might enliven the exercise of the court’s discretionary powers under Part 2.4 of the Act, including as to costs.

These important considerations are now covered in the commentary to assist practitioners, whether acting for a claimant or an estate.

Additionally, the Retainer Instructions have been amended to prompt for this consideration and a new precedent letter has been added to the Acting for the Defendant matter plan. This letter can be used to put the plaintiff’s solicitor on notice when the defendant considers the proceedings have been inappropriately filed in the Supreme Court rather than the County Court.

COVID signing provisions – QLD

by

From 1 July 2021, some of the COVID signing provisions applicable in Queensland during the pandemic will cease.

The Justice Legislation (COVID-19 Emergency Response– Documents and Oaths) Amendment Regulation (No.2) 2021 means that from 1 July any ‘enduring’ documents – wills, enduring powers of attorney, and advance health directives – to be signed by a signatory or substitute signatory need to be made, signed and witnessed under the ordinary law.

One remaining exception is the modified COVID signing provisions that enable nursing practitioners, in addition to doctors, to complete a certificate in an advance health directive stating that the signatory appeared to have the necessary capacity to make it.

This regulation also does not affect the modified arrangements under the Justice Legislation (COVID-19 Emergency Response—Documents and Oaths) Regulation 2020 in relation to the making, signing and witnessing of affidavits, statutory declarations, oaths, deeds, particular mortgages and general powers of attorney under the documents regulation. These measures are currently scheduled to expire on 30 September 2021.

The By Lawyers dedicated Dealing with COVID-19 legal issues commentary will be updated. This guide, accessed via a link at the top of every By Lawyers matter plan, provides practitioners with helpful information about all relevant COVID signing provisions and other important temporary COVID measures.

See the By Lawyers Wills, Powers of Attorney & Advance Health Directives and Mortgages publications for more information. See also the folder of Blank deeds, agreements, statutory declarations and execution clauses in folder A. Getting the matter underway folder on the matter plan in every By Lawyers publication.

Remote execution of powers – VIC

by

Victoria has introduced a permanent procedure for remote execution of powers of attorney, revocations and supportive attorney appointments.

The procedure arises from the temporary COVID-19 related remote execution and witnessing laws, that are now repealed.

The procedure requires:

  1. A special witness, who can be an Australian legal practitioner or justice of the peace;
  2. All steps of the procedure to be completed on the same day and within Victoria;
  3. The principal to sign – or direct someone to sign the instrument on their behalf, with that direction being heard by the witnesses – with all witnesses seeing the signature by audio visual link, or a combination of physical presence and audio visual link;
  4. The special witness to be the last person to witness;
  5. The document to be emailed to any witness attending by audio visual link, who must:
    • be reasonably satisfied that the document is the same document they witnessed the principal sign;
    • certify that they witnessed the document by audio visual link in accordance with the procedure;
    • sign the document, with the principal and other witnesses seeing them to do via audio visual link; and
    • in the case of the special witness, certify the document was signed and witnessed in accordance with the procedure, certify that they are a special witness and the type of special witness they are and note whether there is a recording of the process.

The By Lawyers Powers and advance care directives (Vic) guide has been updated accordingly for the new procedures on remote execution of powers. For LEAP users Power of Attorney forms have been updated as noted in the LEAP forms blog.

Remote execution of wills – VIC

by

Victoria has introduced a permanent procedure for remote execution of wills.

The procedure arises from the temporary COVID-19 related remote execution and witnessing laws, that are now repealed.

The remote execution of wills requires:

  1. A special witness, who can be an Australian legal practitioner or justice of the peace;
  2. All steps of the procedure to be completed on the same day and within Victoria;
  3. The testator to sign the will – or to direct someone to sign the will on their behalf, with that direction being heard by the witnesses – with all witnesses seeing the signature by audio visual link, or a combination of physical presence and audio visual link;
  4. The special witness to be the last person to witness the will;
  5. The will to be emailed to any witness attending by audio visual link, who must:
    • be reasonably satisfied that the will is the same document they witnessed the testator sign;
    • ensure that there is a statement on the will noting that the witness witnessed the will being signed by audio visual link in accordance with the procedure;
    • sign the will, with the testator clearly seeing them do so by audio visual link; and
    • in the case of the special witness, check to ensure the will complies with the remote execution procedure and also ensure there is a statement on the will noting that the will was witnessed in accordance with the procedure and that they are a special witness and note whether there is a recording of the remote execution process.

The procedure for remote execution of wills also applies to revoking or altering an existing will.

The By Lawyers Wills (Vic) guide has been updated accordingly. This includes the addition of two new jurat clause precedents to the matter plan: Remote execution procedure – Witness and Remote execution procedure – Special witness.

Wills guide review – TAS

by

The continuing commitment of By Lawyers to updating and enhancing our publications has seen a Tasmanian Wills guide review completed.

Subscribers using this publication will find a re-ordered and extended matter plan, plus a revised and updated commentary.

The commentary revisions and enhancements arising from this Wills guide review include:

  • The Overview has been expanded and re-ordered;
  • Additional practical guidance added under the new heading ‘Taking instructions for wills’;
  • New commentary on testamentary capacity and the test set out in the leading case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549 at 565;
  • Enhanced commentary and links to legislative provisions regarding the formal requirements for a valid will;
  • Newly consolidated commentary under  new heading: Revocation, marriage, divorce and revival;
  • Expanded commentary on Informal wills, with links to cases;
  • Re-ordered section on the rules of succession on intestacy, with relevant links to the Intestacy Act 2010 and the Relationships Act 2003;
  • Expanded commentary on executors and trustees, including solicitors as executors;
  • New commentary section focusing on the requirements for valid execution of a will, including issues such as blind witnesses, gifts to witnesses, and solicitors as witnesses;
  • Extensive discussion of the law on challenges to the validity of a will;
  • A new section called Finalising the matter which emphasises the importance of terminating the retainer.

A new To Do List precedent has also been added to the matter plan, under Folder A. Getting the matter underway. The new precedent provides a checklist of all usual and necessary steps in the preparation of a will for a client. The To Do list will assist practitioners and their support teams with both workflow and risk-management.

Special grants of probate – NSW

by

A recent Supreme Court case on special grants of probate has been added to 101 Succession Answers NSW. Application of Penhall and Dutton; Estate of the late Kylie Anne Dutton [2021] NSWSC 79 relates to an application for special administration ad colligenda bona defuncti, whereby a grant is obtained to protect the estate.

In this case the deceased’s home was unoccupied for 6 months with no insurance cover, which presented a real risk of diminishing the value of the estate. The Court granted the application to allow the property to be sold and the proceeds placed in an interest bearing account. The Court noted this was an interim measure and a full grant was still required to distribute the estate.

The By Lawyers Probate and Letters and Administration commentaries and 101 Succession Answers all deal with special grants. These apply when there is no one able to seek a grant and there are special needs for the estate. The special grants include:

  • Administration de bonis non administrates cum testamento annexo – administrator dies before completing the administration of will;
  • Administration de bonis non administrates – administrator dies before completing the administration of intestacy;
  • Administration for the purposes of the family provisions claim under s 91 of the Succession Act 2006 – also covered in the By Lawyers Family provision claims guide;
  • Administration pendente lite – s 73 Administration during litigation;
  • Administration ad litem to commence or defend proceedings;
  • Administration by a manager appointed by the Guardianship Division of the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal for a person lacking mental capacity;
  • Administration during minority;
  • Application by a guardian;
  • Administration durante absentia – executor or administrator outside NSW grant to an attorney – s 72;
  • Application under s 76 if executor or administrator out of jurisdiction special administrator may be appointed;
  • Administration when the sole beneficiary/executor/administrator suffers from a disability, he can nominate another; and
  • Grant to a creditor.

The 101 Succession Answers publication can be found in the Reference materials folder at the top of the matter plans in all By Lawyers succession-related guides – Wills, Powers of Attorney, Appointments of enduring guardian and Family provision claims.

Connect with us