obiter | ByLawyers News and Updates

Testamentary discretionary trusts – Foreign person – NSW

By

Testamentary discretionary trusts holding residential property – Surcharge duty and land tax

Where a foreign person acquires or holds residential property, duty and land tax surcharge can apply. Foreign person surcharge duty and land tax can also apply to testamentary discretionary trusts where foreign persons are beneficiaries or potential beneficiaries.

The NSW Commissioner of State Revenue issued a ruling in March 2017 allowing exemption of discretionary trusts from surcharge duty and land tax if the trust deed was amended to exclude foreign beneficiaries within six months of the exemption being granted.

The State Revenue Legislation Further Amendment Bill 2019 is currently before the NSW Parliament. If this Bill is passed, the ability to amend a trust deed to avoid the surcharge will be restricted. Once the Bill passes, the exemption is likely to be removed. The second reading speech for the Bill states: ‘the Government considers that the end of 2019 allows sufficient time for any remaining trustees and their advisers to make necessary changes to trust deeds’.

There is two-year period of grace, from the commencement of the proposed new s 104JA of the Duties Act 1997. During that period, the trustee of a testamentary discretionary trust will not be deemed a foreign person if the deceased was not a foreign person, even if the trust does not prevent a foreign person from being a beneficiary of the trust.

In order to avoid the application of surcharge duty and land tax, the By Lawyers wills creating testamentary discretionary trusts and library of testamentary discretionary trust provisions include a clause titled ‘Foreign beneficiaries’ that prohibits the trustee from making trust distributions to, or otherwise benefiting, a foreign person. The clause must also prohibit an amendment that has the effect of including a beneficiary or potential beneficiary who is a foreign person. Where it is intended for a foreign person to benefit under a testamentary discretionary trust, this clause should be appropriately amended or removed when drafting the will.

It is important to review existing testamentary trust provisions arising under a will and consider whether it is necessary to amend to avoid the application of surcharge duty and land tax.

See the commentary in the Wills (NSW) Guide for further details.

Trusts – Foreign person – NSW

By

Discretionary trusts – foreign person

Where a foreign person acquires or holds residential property, duty and land tax surcharge can apply. Foreign person surcharge duty and land tax can also apply to discretionary trusts where foreign persons are beneficiaries or potential beneficiaries.

The NSW Commissioner of State Revenue issued a ruling in March 2017 allowing exemption of discretionary trusts from surcharge duty and land tax if the trust deed was amended to exclude foreign beneficiaries within six months of the exemption being granted.

The State Revenue Legislation Further Amendment Bill 2019 is currently before the NSW Parliament. If this Bill is passed, the ability to amend a trust deed to avoid the surcharge will be restricted. Once the Bill passes, the exemption is likely to be removed. The second reading speech for the Bill states: ‘the Government considers that the end of 2019 allows sufficient time for any remaining trustees and their advisers to make necessary changes to trust deeds’.

It is therefore important for trustees to review existing discretionary trust deeds and consider whether they require amendment.

In order to avoid the application of surcharge duty and land tax, discretionary trust deeds must include a clause that prohibits the trustee from making trust distributions to, or otherwise benefiting a foreign person. The deed must also prohibit an amendment that has the effect of allowing the trustee to make distributions to, or to otherwise benefit, a foreign person.

The By Lawyers Discretionary Trust deed precedents and commentary have been amended accordingly. A note has also been added to the ‘Retainer Instructions – Trusts’ precedent, to prompt practitioners to raise this issue with clients when drafting trust deeds.

See the commentary in the By Lawyers Trusts Publication for further details.

 

Off the plan contracts – NSW

By

Significant changes to off the plan contracts commenced 1 December 2019.

The changes arise from the Conveyancing Legislation Amendment Act 2018 (NSW) and the Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Amendment Regulation 2019 (NSW). They place further disclosure obligations on vendors. They also create new remedies and stronger protections for purchasers when entering into residential off the plan contracts.

Changes to off the plan contracts – summary:

  • Certain prescribed documents must be attached to residential off the plan contracts. These include a prescribed Disclosure Statement, a draft plan prepared by a registered surveyor and other draft documents, as set out in clause 4A of the Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Regulation 2017.
  • A purchaser can rescind the contract within 14 days if the Disclosure Statement, draft plan or relevant prescribed documents are not attached to off the plan contracts exchanged on or after 1 December 2019.
  • There is an ongoing obligation on the vendor to notify purchasers of changes to material particulars using the prescribed Notice of Changes form. Purchasers may be able to rescind or claim compensation if there is a change to a material particular.
  • The cooling-off period for residential off the plan contracts is extended to 10 business days.
  • The final registered plan must be provided to the purchaser at least 21 days before settlement.
  • Deposits must be retained by the stakeholder in a trust or controlled monies account.

An off the plan contract is defined in the amending act to mean a contract for the sale of a residential lot that does not exist at the time the contract is entered into.

The following are not caught by the amendments:

  • The sale of a commercial property off the plan.
  • The sale of a residential lot off the plan if it is sold at the point when the title is registered but an occupation certificate has not been issued.
  • Contracts arising out of the exercise of an option that was entered into before 1 December 2019.

Updates to By Lawyers publications

  • The By Lawyers Conveyancing Publication, including Sale and Purchase Guides and 1001 Conveyancing Answers, all contain dedicated commentary regarding off the plan contracts. These commentaries now cover the new requirements in detail.
  • The By Lawyers Contract for Sale of Land has been amended as follows:
    • Statutory cooling off notice – 10 business days;
    • Statutory attachments table includes Disclosure Statement;
    • Price and deposit clause addresses the requirement for deposit and instalment payments to be held as trust or controlled money;
    • New clause 16(d) ‘Residential off the plan contracts’; and
    • Off the plan settlement changed to 21 days after notice of registration of plan.
  • All precedents making reference to cooling off periods have been updated to accord with the new period.
  • Disclosure Statement and Notice of Changes forms are available on the Sale matter plan.
  • New notices for rescission and compensation claims have been added to the ‘Claims, disputes and notices’ folder. Precedent letters serving these notices on the relevant parties have also been added.

By Lawyers are proud to assist subscribers to understand and comply with these amendments. Like all By Lawyers publications, our Conveyancing Guides provide all the necessary commentary and precedents in one place. Enjoy practice more!

 

 

Interpreters – NSW

By

The rules concerning the engagement or appointment of interpreters for civil litigation in NSW courts have been amended.

The Uniform Civil Procedure (Amendment No 92) Rule 2019 provides for new rules. These are based on the Model Rules in Recommended National Standards for Working with Interpreters in Courts and Tribunals prepared by the Judicial Council on Cultural Diversity.

The amendments that commenced on 8 November add Division 3 of Part 31 and Schedule 7A to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). The new division sets out rules which cover:

  • When an interpreter may be engaged;
  • Who may act as an interpreter; and
  • Functions of interpreters.

Importantly, an interpreter must now adhere to the Court Interpreters’ Code of Conduct, which is set out in Schedule 7A of the UCPR. A copy needs to be given to the interpreter as soon as possible after they have been engaged or appointed.

The By Lawyers Litigation publications for Local, District and Supreme Courts have been updated accordingly. A link to the Code of Conduct is included.

Off the plan amendments – NSW

By

Off the plan amendments

Off the plan amendments for residential properties are being introduced by the Conveyancing Legislation (Amendment) Act 2018 and the Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Amendment Regulation 2019. The bulk of the amendments will commence on 1 December 2019, however, the provisions affecting statutory cooling off commenced on 25 October 2019, introducing a transition period until 30 November 2019.

The cooling off period for off-the-plan contracts has been extended from 5 to 10 business days. The cooling off warning notice form, prescribed by Schedule 5 of the Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Regulation 2017, has also been amended to reflect this change. A contract for the sale of residential property entered into during the transitional period may include the new cooling off warning notice form or the old form in force immediately before the amendment. There is no obligation for a contract to include the new form of notice until 1 December 2019. 

A summary of the amendments that will commence 1 December 2019 include:

  • Increased vendor disclosure requirements including a Disclosure Statement and draft documents to be attached to the contract. Purchasers can rescind the contract within 14 days of exchange if the Disclosure Statement or relevant prescribed documents are not attached to an off-the-plan contract before it is signed. These new requirements are additional to the existing disclosure regime imposed by Part 2 of the Conveyancing (Sale of Land) Regulation 2017. There is no need to attach more than one copy of the same document to the contract and the Disclosure Statement;
  • Vendors to notify changes to ‘material particulars’. Purchasers can rescind or claim compensation for some changes to material particulars. Notification of changes must be made on an approved form which will be available on the By Lawyers Sale matter plan soon;
  • 10-Business-Day cooling-off period. All contracts for sale of land may use either the old form or new form of warning notice until 30 November 2019. Contracts for established properties may use the old form or new form of warning notice for 6 months after commencement. From 2 June 2020, all contracts for sale, whether for off-the-plan or established properties, will need to use the new form of cooling off warning notice;
  • Purchasers to be given registered plans 21 days before settlement;
  • Deposit to be held in trust. Any money paid by the purchaser by way of deposit or installment under the contract must be retained by the stakeholder in a trust or controlled money account during the contract period. This money cannot be released to the vendor before settlement. This measure will ensure deposit and instalment monies are protected in the event of the developer’s insolvency;
  • Stronger sunset clause protections. The amendments extend the definition of a sunset clause to capture other events which trigger termination of the contract, like the issue of an occupation certificate. Changes also confirm that the Court can award damages if the vendor is permitted to end the contract under a sunset clause. These changes are contained in new Section 66ZS introduced by the Conveyancing Legislation (Amendment) Act 2018. New sunset clause provisions will apply to all off-the-plan contracts, irrespective of whether they were signed before or after commencement.

The By Lawyers Conveyancing (NSW) Publication will be updated accordingly. This will include new provisions in the By Lawyers Contract for the sale of land 2019, precedents and commentary.

Workers Compensation – NSW

By

The By Lawyers Workers Compensation – NSW publication has been updated.

The final provisions of the Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 2018 commenced on 21 October 2019.

The amendments include the introduction of a simplified process to determine an injured worker’s pre-injury average weekly earnings.

The new Schedule 3 to the Workers Compensation Act 1987 provides the method for determining pre-injury average weekly earnings. Insurers and workers may now agree on a figure.

The relevant section of the By Lawyers Workers Compensation – NSW commentary has been updated accordingly.

Mine subsidence certificates – NSW

By

Mine subsidence certificates have been abolished in NSW.

From 30 September 2019, certificates of compliance for properties under Section 15 of the former Mine Subsidence Compensation Act 1961 are no longer available from Subsidence Advisory NSW.

Subsidence Advisory NSW’s records indicate the vast majority of developments in mine subsidence districts are approved structures. In the last ten years, only four claims for homes have been refused due to the structure being non-compliant. Due to the extremely low likelihood of a claim being made for a non-compliant property, the significant cost increase to adequately undertake compliance checks prior to issuing certificates was deemed unwarranted.

As a result, the certificates were not carried over to the Coal Mine Subsidence Compensation Act 2017. Property owners are afforded the following alternative protections under the Act:

  • Subsidence Advisory NSW has discretion to pay a claim for subsidence damage to a contravening development in circumstances where the failure to obtain the relevant approvals was not the fault of the property owner or where exceptional circumstances exist.
  • Under Section 23(a) of the Act, buyers have the right to withdraw from a contract of sale for a structure that does not comply with Subsidence Advisory NSW’s development requirements.

Prospective purchasers who wish to ascertain whether a structure is eligible for compensation can do so by obtaining confirmation of development approval through the vendor or council.

Online applications for intervention orders – VIC

By

Online applications for intervention orders are now available for family violence related matters, via the Magistrates’ Court website.

Amendments to the Family Violence Protection Act 2008 which commenced on 31 July 2019 allow an applicant to apply online, instead of attending in person at a police station or magistrates  court. Online applications for intervention orders take about 15 minutes to complete. They can be saved, amended and lodged at any time within 4 weeks of being started.

Police can also make the online application on someone’s behalf.

There is no requirement for the application to be sworn or witnessed. Rather, when completing the online application the applicant must make a declaration of truth as to the contents of the application. Making a deliberately false declaration of truth is an offence carrying serious penalties – up to 600 penalty units and 5 years imprisonment. The applicant must also acknowledge their understanding of that offence and those penalties when completing the application.

When deciding whether to make an interim order based on an online application, the Magistrates’ Court can waive the requirement that the application be supported by oral evidence or an affidavit. Before waiving the requirement the court must consider whether it is practicable to obtain oral evidence or an affidavit before the order is made.

The By Lawyers guide Intervention Orders (VIC) has been updated to cover online applications for intervention orders. This publication is located in the By Lawyers Criminal – Magistrates’ Court guide.

Assistance for potential applicants and background information on the new process is available from the Neighbourhood Justice Centre via the Magistrates’ Court website.

E-conveyancing from 1 July 2019 – NSW

By

In a continuation of the transition to E-conveyancing version 5 of the Conveyancing Rules replace version 4 from 1 July 2019.

Version 5 of the rules provide that all mainstream dealings including transfers, mortgages, discharges of mortgage, caveats, withdrawals of caveat and transmission applications, or combinations thereof, must be lodged electronically when signed on or after 1 July 2019, except where a waiver applies.

Waivers

Waivers apply to certain transactions that are not able to be lodged electronically.

The following waivers which operate from 1 July 2019 in conjunction with Conveyancing Rules version 5 have now been published:

If eligible for a waiver, a Conveyancing Rules Exception form will need to be complete at the point of lodgement. This form is available in the sale and purchase matter plans.

An Alert has been added to the by Lawyers Conveyancing Sale and Purchase matter plans regarding the 1 July 2019 mandate.

Keep up to date with By Lawyers

By Lawyers keep you up to date with E-conveyancing. A brief explanation of the transition to E-conveyancing in the By Lawyers Conveyancing Sale and Purchase matter plans can provide further assistance.

Off the plan – sunset clauses – VIC

By

Vendors face new restrictions when seeking to activate sunset clauses to end off the plan contracts in Victoria.

Amendments for off the plan contracts

The Sale of Land Amendment Act 2019 commenced on 4 June 2019. It amends the Sale of Land Act 1962. The amendments require vendors wishing to end residential off the plan contracts pursuant to a sunset clause to either obtain the purchaser’s consent, or an order from the Supreme Court.

New notice requirements created by section 13 of the amending Act for off-the-plan contracts for residential land including a sunset clause, have yet to commence.

The changes do not affect the existing statutory rights of purchasers to end a contract if the plan of subdivision is not approved by the sunset date.

Rescission

Section 10A of the Sale of Land Act 1962 provides that if a sunset clause in a contract allows the vendor to rescind the contract, then rescission must be in accordance with the Act. Section 10C overcomes any inconsistent contractual provision.

Purchaser’s consent

Section 10B of the Sale of Land Act prohibits a vendor from relying on a sunset clause unless the vendor obtains the purchaser’s written consent to any such rescission.

A vendor seeking to obtain the purchaser’s consent must give the purchaser 28 days notice setting out the reason that the vendor proposes to rescind, the reason for the delay in registration of the plan and that the purchaser is not obliged to consent to the proposed rescission.

A precedent ‘Notice of rescission of off the plan contract’ in accordance with s 10B(3) can be found on the By Lawyers matter plan.

Court order

Section 10D of the Sale of Land Act provides that the vendor may apply to the Supreme Court for an order permitting the vendor to rescind a contract pursuant to a sunset clause. The Court must consider a wide variety of matters relating to the contract and the property, including increase in value. If an order is made it may include compensation to the purchaser and the vendor will be liable for the purchaser’s costs.

Notice

Section 10F, created by section 13 of the Amendment Act, has yet to commence. This new section will require residential off-the-plan contracts that include a sunset clause to include a notice informing the purchaser that:

  • the vendor may give a notice proposing to rescind the contract;
  • the purchaser may consent to rescission, but is not obliged to consent;
  • the vendor may apply to the court for an order permitting rescission;
  • the court may make such an order.

A precedent notice in compliance with s 10F will be included in General Condition 9 of the By Lawyers contract on commencement of s 10F.

By Lawyers contract

The general conditions and particulars of sale in the By Lawyers Contract satisfy all of the statutory requirements when selling prior to registration, relying on the default sunset period of 18 months.

Connect with us