ByLawyers News and Updates

Mental impairment – WA

by

The Criminal Law (Mental Impairment) Act 2023 replaces the Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996 from 1 September 2024.

The purposes of the new Act are:

  • to make provision in relation to criminal proceedings involving persons with mental impairment;
  • to provide for special criminal proceedings for persons who are unfit to stand trial;
  • to provide for the supervision of persons who, in special criminal proceedings, are found to have committed an offence;
  • to provide for the supervision of persons acquitted on account of mental impairment;
  • to provide for the safe reintegration into the community of persons supervised under this Act;
  • to repeal the Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996 and the Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Regulations 1997;
  • for related purposes.

Part 3 of the Criminal Law (Mental Impairment) Act 2023 applies to accused who are unfit to stand trial on criminal charges.

Division 2 of that Part deals with raising and deciding the question of whether an accused is fit to stand trial on criminal charges. There is a presumption of fitness that can be rebutted if the accused is found to be unable to do one or more of the things listed in s 26, which include:

  • understand the nature of the charge;
  • give instructions;
  • understand the requirement to plead, or the effect of a plea;
  • follow the course of a trial; or
  • properly defend the charge.

The question of fitness can be raised at any time before or during a trial.

Under s 29, the court decides the question of fitness to stand trial on the balance of probabilities and may inform itself in any way it considers appropriate, including with medical evidence.

The Mental Health section of the Full Commentary in the By Lawyers Magistrates Court – Criminal (WA) guide has been updated accordingly.

Mental health provisions – NSW

by

Mental health provisions in the criminal courts have had their first substantive overhaul in 30 years. The Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act 2020 commenced on 27 March 2021. Division 2, Part 2 of the new Act applies to criminal offences in the Local Court.

The Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act 2020 replaces the Mental Health (Forensic Provisions) Act 1990, including what were previously known as ‘section 32 applications’. This re-set of mental health provisions in the criminal context provides a diversionary scheme for people with mental health and cognitive impairment issues who are charged with offences that may be dealt with summarily.

Under s 12 of the Act, if it appears to a magistrate that a defendant has, or had at the time of the commission of the offence, a mental health impairment or a cognitive impairment, or both, then the magistrate can make an order under s 14 to dismiss the charge either conditionally or unconditionally. The magistrate may also adjourn the proceedings under s 13 for assessment or diagnosis, preparation of a treatment plan or to identify a responsible person for the purpose of making an order.

The main changes from the existing law – apart from the new section numbers – are:

  • ‘mental health impairment’ is now defined’;
  • the existing definition of ‘cognitive impairment’ is slightly amended;
  • the new Act sets out what the magistrate can consider when deciding whether to make an order, although the court retains ultimate discretion; and
  • magistrates can now re-call people who are discharged on conditions under the Act, which they fail to comply with, for a period of 12 rather than 6 months.

These changes should see more people with mental health or cognitive impairments successfully diverted from the criminal justice system.

The By Lawyers Criminal Law publication has been updated accordingly. The existing commentary on section 32 applications has been moved to an Appendix at the end of the commentary, as the previous legislation continues to apply to matters which were already on foot before 27 March 2021.

 

Connect with us