ByLawyers News and Updates

Costs agreements – All states

by

Enhancement of By Lawyers costs agreements

All By Lawyers costs agreements have been reviewed, consolidated, and reformatted to ensure they are in strict compliance with all applicable regulatory requirements in each state and territory, and to improve presentation and readability.

A good cost agreement precedent provides transparency, reduces disputes with clients over fees, and ensures that firms get paid. It is important these documents are correct, however, the increasing complexity of cost disclosure requirements makes this difficult. By Lawyers precedents provide firms with accurate and effective costs agreements for all matter types in all jurisdictions.

Summary of key changes

  • A key enhancement is the inclusion of a Terms and Conditions section, which consolidates general information that applies across all matters.
  • All related information has been grouped together to assist with readability and comprehension.
  • A Next steps section has been added, outlining the steps required to be taken by the client to move the engagement forward.
  • The automation in relation to fees, disbursements, and internal expenses has been improved for LEAP users.
  • The scopes of work, now available under each cost agreement on the matter plans, have been enhanced. For LEAP users, scopes of work can be added to a costs agreement via the Insert Clause feature. See Inserting a Clause on the LEAP Community page. Alternatively, all users can simply cut and paste the scope into the precedent.

New categories of costs agreements

The By Lawyers costs agreements have been simplified into 4 categories in most states and territories:

  1. Costs agreement: suitable for most matters.
  2. Costs agreement – Estate administration: specific to applications for probate and letters of administration and administering the estate.
  3. Conditional costs agreement: suitable for litigation such as personal injury claims where the firm agrees to act on a no win no fee basis.
  4. Conditional costs agreement – Uplift fee: suitable for litigation in jurisdictions where the relevant legislation permits an uplift to be applied to the total costs for a successful outcome.

The new costs agreements and scopes of work have been added, as appropriate, to folder A. Getting the matter underway on all matter plans.

County Court – VIC

by

Common Law Division Practice Note PNCLD 1-2025 takes effect in the County Court from 25 March 2025 and replaces 21 existing practice notes.

The new practice note, which stretches to 159 pages and includes a dictionary setting out key definitions, covers all the practices and case management expectations for all proceedings in the Common Law Division, including for the various specialist lists, and Appeals.

The new Common Law Division practice note supersedes the following practice notes:

  • PNCLD 1-2023 Common Law Division practice note
  • PNCLD 2-2023 Serious injury applications practice note
  • PNCLD 3-2022 WorkCover List practice note
  • PNCLD 4-2023 Family Property List practice note
  • PNCLD 5-2023 Medical List practice note
  • PNCLD 6-2023 Confiscation List practice note
  • PNCLD 7-2023 Defamation List practice note
  • PNCLD 8-2023 Adoptions, Surrogacy and Name Change List practice note
  • PNCLD 12-2023 Applications for approval of compromise practice note
  • PNCLD 13-2022 Applications by a solicitor for costs in work injury damages claims practice note
  • PNCLD 14-2023 Applications to file a notice of ceasing to act practice note
  • PNCLD 15-2023 Applications to take evidence by deposition practice note
  • PNCLD 16-2023 Information Technology (IT) practice note
  • PNCLD 17-2023 Judicial mediation practice note
  • PNCLD 18-2023 Subpoenas practice note
  • PNCLD 19-2023 Institutional Liability List practice note
  • PNCLD SP-2-2022 Suppression, pseudonym (and like) order applications practice note
  • PNCLD SA 2-2022 Applications for compensation under s85B of the Sentencing Act 1991 practice note
  • PNCLD SO 2-2022 Applications for supervision orders under the Serious Offenders Act 2018 practice note
  • PNCLD FV 2-2024 Family Violence and Personal Safety Intervention Order appeals practice note
  • PNCI 9-2021 eCase: electronic subpoenas practice note.

The specialist lists dealt with by the practice note are:

  • The Civil Claims lists: Serious Injury List; WorkCover List; Medical List; Institutional Liability List; Defamation List; Family Property List; and the General List.
  • Adoptions, Surrogacy and Name Changes List.
  • Confiscation List.
  • Appeals and Post Sentence Application List.

Commentary links for both Acting for the Plaintiff and Acting for the Defendant in the By Lawyers County Court (VIC) publication have been updated accordingly.

500-page limit – PIC – NSW

by

A 500-page limit applies for documents lodged with most applications or replies in the Personal Injury Commission (PIC) from 25 November 2024.

The Personal Injury Commission deals with disputes about injuries sustained in motor accidents and workplaces in New South Wales.

Intent of the rule

The new rule is intended to assist the Personal Injury Commission in conducting its proceedings justly, quickly, cost effectively and with as little formality as possible.

It will focus the parties’ attention on the real issues in dispute and will ensure that the process is efficient which will reduce process trauma for claimants.

The rule will also reduce the amount of highly personal information that is filed with the Commission which in turn will assist the Commission with its approach to cyber security.

Exclusions

The 500-page limit does not apply:

For motor vehicle accident claims, in certain:

  • medical review panel proceedings;
  • merit review panel proceedings;
  • merit review proceedings; and
  • settlement approvals;

For workers compensation claims, in certain:

  • expedited assessment proceedings;
  • medical appeal panel proceedings;
  • presidential proceedings; and
  • work injury damages and related proceedings.

Additional documents

If additional documents are relevant to the real issues in dispute in a matter before the PIC, they may be able to be lodged either by consent if the proceedings relate to medical assessments, or otherwise with leave on application.

Application to lodge additional documents

Applications to lodge additional documents must be made no later than 14 days before a medical assessment, or no later than 3 working days before any conference or hearing for any other dispute type. Only one application is permissible in proceedings unless leave is granted.

Transition period

There is no transition period. The new rule applies from 25 November.

The By Lawyers Workers Compensation (NSW) and Motor Vehicle Accidents (NSW) – Accidents from 1 December 2017 publications have been updated to reflect the new rule.

Costs – All states

by

By Lawyers 101 Costs Answers reference manual has been extensively reviewed and enhanced.

This comprehensive reference manual is available in the Reference materials folder on all By Lawyers matters plans. The 101 Costs Answers guide is also as part of the By Lawyers Practice Management publication.

Commentary enhancement

An important new section of commentary has been included dealing with disclosure before settlement in litigation matters. Barrister Philippe Doyle Gray, who we are delighted to welcome to the ranks of our authors, covers in detail the requirement under the Legal Profession Uniform Law for clients to receive advice about the cost implications of settlement. Philippe has also made his helpful Settlement Computer available via a link in the By Lawyers commentaries. This automated spreadsheet assists practitioners with the sometimes complicated calculations required to properly give disclosure before settlement, taking into account the various possibilities for the resolution of a matter.

The new section of commentary has been added to the By Lawyers litigation and injuries guides in those states where the Legal Profession Uniform Law applies, namely New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia.

New precedents

Two new precedent letters to the client have been added to provide clients with the necessary disclosure before settlement:

  • Letter to client – Costs disclosure before settlement – NSW, VIC and WA;
  • Letter to client – Costs disclosure before settlement – QLD, SA, TAS, ACT and NT.

There is one precedent letter for Legal Profession Uniform Law states and one for the other jurisdictions where costs disclosure before settlement is not mandatory but is nonetheless best practice.

These new letters are available in the If required – Updating costs disclosure and security for costs folder on all By Lawyers matter plans. They are also available on the relevant litigation and injuries matter plans under Going to court.

Costs agreements

By Lawyers extensive suite of costs agreements that comply with the regulatory requirements in each state are currently under review. Keep an eye out for a future News & Updates post when the revised versions are published.

Motor accident claims portal – NSW

by

The Personal Injury Commission has introduced an online motor accident claims portal for electronic lodgement and document management.

The Commission’s Pathway portal went live on 20 June. All new matters are now lodged using the new portal and existing matters have been migrated.

Division 4.3 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 deals with lodgement of documents into the Commission’s Electronic Case Management (ECM) system, now called Pathway.

See the Commission website for information on how to access Pathway. Practitioners must register and obtain login access.

The new motor accident claims portal is intended to allow for the creation and management of documents and related information in a matter. The parties and the Commission can also communicate through the platform.

The Commission’s website provides extensive information for practitioners, including a detailed online course that steps practitioners through how to:

  • Lodge an application in Pathway Portal
  • Complete a reply request
  • View a reply
  • Send and receive messages
  • View allocation details
  • View outcome documents

The By Lawyers Motor Vehicle Accident – From 1 Dec 2017 guide has been updated accordingly.

Motor vehicle accident – NSW

by

Entitlements for people injured in motor vehicle accident claims under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 have become easier to access.

From 1 April 2023, weekly statutory benefits can be obtained from the date of a motor vehicle accident, even if sought more than 28 days after the date of the accident. The 28 day timeframe was previously a strict requirement.

Now, the claim for weekly benefits can be lodged within three months of the motor vehicle accident, if accompanied by a full and satisfactory explanation for the delay in making the claim.

Whether the claimant has a full and satisfactory explanation for the delay is determined by reference to the factors set out in the regulations, namely whether the claimant was aware of the right to make the claim, was under a legal incapacity, or was prevented from making the claim before the expiry of the 28 day period because of illness or injury.

The insurer has 14 days to reject the claimant’s explanation, otherwise it is taken to be a full and satisfactory explanation.

See cl 8A of the Motor Accident Injuries Regulation 2017 and s 6.13 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

The following updates to the Motor Accident Guidelines MAG 9.1 also take effect from 1 April 2023:

  • the defined term Minor injury is replaced by Threshold injury; and
  • eligibility for statutory benefits is extended from 26 weeks to 52 weeks for injured persons with a threshold injury who are wholly or partly at fault for the accident.

These changes arise from the commencement of provisions under the Motor Accident Injuries Amendment Act 2022. Refer to our previous News and Updates post from 5 December 2022 for the other amendments under that Act.

The By Lawyers Motor Vehicle Accidents (NSW) – Accidents from 1 December 2017 guide has been updated accordingly.

CTP claims costs – NSW

by

Reporting of CTP claims costs by legal practitioners in NSW is now lodged via an online portal.

The State Insurance Regulatory Authority (SIRA) has launched a new Claims Costs Disclosure (CCD) portal to capture settlement costs data relating to Compulsory Third Party (CTP) damages claims made under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAIA).

Legal practitioners representing a CTP claimant must provide SIRA with a breakdown of costs related to the settlement of the claim, including:

  • the total amount for which the claim was resolved;
  • all deductions, including all legal costs and disbursements;
  • the total amount paid to the claimant.

CTP claims costs for damages claims settled on or after 1 March 2023 need to be lodged via the new portal. Retrospective disclosure prior to 1 March 2023 is not required. Registration for the portal has been available since 8 February 2023.

The By Lawyers Motor Vehicle Accident – From 1 December 2017 (NSW) guide has been updated accordingly.

Transport Accident Claims – VIC

by

Amendments that extend entitlements to compensation under the transport accident claims legislation have commenced.

Part 3 of the Road Safety Legislation Amendment Act 2022  commenced on 6 July 2022. It amends the Transport Accident Act 1986 to extend benefits for claimants and their supporting families. The definition of a dependent child is amended to include a child who is under the age of 18 years, rather than 16 years. The definition of an immediate family member is amended to include a grandchild, alongside a partner, parent, grandparent, child, and sibling.

The extension of the definitions means that family counseling is available for the grandchildren of grandparents severely injured or killed in a transport accident. Claims can also be made for travel or accommodation expenses for grandchildren visiting their injured grandparent in hospital after a transport accident or attending the funeral of their, grandparent killed in a transport accident and to provide a replacement carer if the grandparent was the primary carer for the grandchild.

New provisions have been added to the Transport Accident Act that deal with the pre-accident weekly earnings for various types of earners who were, immediately before a transport accident, already receiving a weekly payment in respect of total or partial loss of earnings suffered as a result of, or materially contributed to by, an injury resulting from a previous transport accident.

The amending Act also clarifies the Transport Accident Commission’s capacity to disclose information to other statutory agencies and expands its ability to prosecute fraud offences committed with respect to transport accident claims.

The full commentary in the By Lawyers Transport Accident Claims (VIC) publication has been updated accordingly.

Unrelated provisions of the amending Act which affect the Road Safety Act 1986 have not yet commenced. These will be the subject of further update and publication amendments in due course.

Amendment of the PIC rules – NSW

by

Recent amendment of the PIC rules impacts procedure for motor accident claims and workers compensation claims in the Personal Injury Commission.

The Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 govern proceedings in both of the Commission’s divisions. The rules have received their first review since the PIC commenced operations. The review has resulted in a number of relatively minor tweaks and additions, and one substantial change.

The minor amendments include:

  • provision for consistency across the divisions as to the material that is lodged in applications;
  • provision for compliance with notices for production across divisions;
  • procedure for lodgment and admission of surveillance recordings;
  • provision for SIRA to intervene in Merit Review Panel proceedings;
  • clarification that an application to refer a medical dispute for assessment can be may be made at any time.

Amendment to time limits for appeals

The substantial amendment relates to time limits. An anomaly in the legislation that established the PIC meant that there has until now been no discretion for the Commission to extend the time for an application or appeal beyond the 28-day period provided in the Act. The legislation has now amended to alleviate that situation, and a new Rule 133A is included in this amendment of the PIC rules to enable the time for applications and appeals to be extended where necessary.

The criteria for extension of time under the new rule is that, for the applicant to lose the right to lodge would result in demonstrable and substantial injustice.

The commentaries in By Lawyers Motor Accident Claims – from 1 December 2017 and Workers Compensation publications have been amended accordingly.

Personal Injury Commission – NSW

by

Overview

From 1 March 2021 the Personal Injury Commission (PIC) became the ‘one-stop shop’ for dispute resolution for workers compensation and motor accident claims in NSW.

The PIC has two divisions with a single point of entry via an online portal. The PIC takes over from the Workers Compensation Commission, which has been abolished. The PIC also takes over most of the dispute resolution functions from the State Insurance Regulatory Authority (SIRA) regarding motor accident claims.

The idea of the consolidation is to gain efficiencies via a single entity, especially with medical assessments and medical dispute determination. Medical assessors for both workers compensation and motor accidents claims, along with merit reviewers for motor accident matters and mediators for workers compensation matters, are appointed by the President of the PIC and operate under the PIC legislation.

The substantive law does not change.

The By Lawyers Workers Compensation and Motor Accidents publications – both Prior to 1 December 2017 and From 1 December 2017 – have all been be amended.

Legislation

Personal Injury Commission Act 2020;

Personal Injury Commission Regulation 2020; and

Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021.

What the PIC does

The PIC is not a court but is headed by a President, who is a judge of a court of record. The PIC will publish its decisions.

The two divisions, Motor Accidents and Workers Compensation, have a common registry, and common practice and procedure wherever possible.

The PIC replaces the Workers Compensation Commission and determines all disputes under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 and the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

Disputes in relation to claims under the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 (MAIA) and the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (MACA) previously managed and resolved by SIRA are now dealt with by the Personal Injury Commission. The PIC also takes over from the Motor Accidents Claims Assessment and Resolution Service (CARS) and the Medical Assessment Service (MAS).

The Act requires the PIC to deal with proceedings justly, quickly, cost-effectively and with as little formality as possible.

The rules of evidence do not apply and proceedings must be as informal as possible, including telephone conferences instead of formal hearings.

What the PIC does not do

Disputed common law damages claims still go to the District or Supreme Court. However, the PIC must mediate the dispute first and/or provide a certificate before proceedings can be commenced.

As it is not a court, the PIC cannot determine matters that involve federal jurisdiction. The PIC Act provides a mechanism to send proceedings that involve federal jurisdiction to the District Court.

The Workers Compensation Independent Review Office (WIRO) is now known as the Independent Review Office (IRO). It continues to manage disputes regarding insurers previously managed by WIRO, with the addition of CTP insurers for motor accident claims. IRO also continues WIRO’s previous responsibility for the funding of workers compensation claims via the existing ILARS grants.

No change to the substantive law

The establishment of the PIC and the transfer to it of dispute resolution functions does not affect the underlying substantive law.

There is no change to the entitlements of injured persons to damages, benefits and entitlements under either workers compensation or motor accidents legislation.

Transitional provisions

Transitional provisions are set out in the Personal Injury Commission Regulation 2020.

For existing matters – that is, claims lodged before the commencement of the PIC on 1 March 2021 – the PIC deals with disputes and medical assessments. However it does so under the previous legislative framework – so the Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2011 and the existing provisions of the motor accidents legislation. That includes appeals, so for any arbitrated decision that was heard before 1 March 2021, but which is appealed after 1 March 2021, the appeal proceeds on the basis of the pre-existing legislation.

By Lawyers keeps you up to date!

All relevant By Lawyers publications have been updated in line with the commencement of the Personal Injury Commission. Commentary and precedents have been amended, replaced or added wherever required in our Workers Compensation, Motor Accidents and District Court publications.

Connect with us